Home | About Us | Subscriptions | Advertising | El Centinela
Catholic Sentinel | Portland, OR Wednesday, February 10, 2016
CYO Football 2015 2015 Priest Reassignments, Archdiocese of Portland Cardinal Francis George dies Mothering with faith Sisters of the Holy Names, 2015 Live Nativity at St. John the Baptist 2014 Fall CYO results Catholic Charities Donor Lunch 2014 Year of Consecrated Life opening Mass Holy Spirit Sisters Jubilee 2014 Seaside youth conference Mount Angel 125th Northwest Hub Furlow at papal Mass 2014 Rosary Bowl NW Brother André 2014 Fall 40 Days for Life 2014 Inauguration of Fr. Mark Poorman Coffee shop at abbey First day of school, 2014 Regis High School 50th anniversary 2014 Crooked Finger Pilgrimage Mass with migrant farm workers Maronite Ordination Consecration to "Immaculate Heart of Our Lady of Fatima" CYO track Southern Oregon Evangelization 2014 Priest Ordination Christ the King youth 2014 priest reassignments Our Lady of Lavang Confirmation, 2014 Memorial Day 2014 2014 Transitional deacon ordination Padre Foster Granados visits Albany Bishop Smith ordination Canonization of Pope John Paul II, Pope John XXIII Bishop Peter Smith 2014 Easter Vigil 2014 Walk of Cross 2014 Chrism Mass CYO basketball 2014 St. Patrick of the Forest 150th Catholic Charities Celebration of Hope, 2014 Boys2Men Archbishop visits Oregon State Penitentiary 40 Day Vigil for Life, 2014 Pope Francis creates new cardinals St. Henry shelter 2014 CYO swimming Funeral of Fr. George Wolf Travel on a budget Lunar New Year, 2014 Tech in Catholic schools 2014 Right to Life Rally Archbishop visits Santiam Prison First Mass in Oregon Milwaukie Posada St. Francis, Sherwood, Toy Drive Central Catholic football Typhoon Haiyan Deacon Ordination/ Kresbach, Schmitt A Catholic fisherman St. Cecilia Centennial Southern Oregon Welcome Mass Shepherd of the Valley, Central Point, dedication Grotto Anniversary 2013 Champions of Faith Dinner Gardenripe farms Coleman hop farm Corvallis Year of Faith Archbishop Howard at St. Rose Hitchhiking priests Franciscan Spiritual Center Sacred Heart, Medford Migrant Mass Tanzanians' jubilee World Youth Day 2013 2013 Blessing of the Animals 2013 Freedom Mass Albany school closure Fabric art Megan graduates from Catholic school St. Vincent de Paul Hillsboro 2013 Deacon ordination Sister Theresa Lamkin St. Helen Mission, Brownsville Marist Brainiacs St. Mary, Eugene St. Francis eighth graders Ascension confirmation 2013 Pastoral Ministry Conference St. Joseph Salem — Year of Faith Archbishop Sample's Installation Mass 2013 Archbishop Sample Chrism Mass 2013 2013 Young Catholics Pope Francis inauguration Celebration of Hope Vlazny Farewell Mass Archbishop Vlazny Farewell St. Paul Church in St. Paul Valley Catholic Green Building Rite of Election 2013 Water summit 2013 Lunar New Year Alveda King in Eugene New Monsignors, 2013 2013 Right to Life Rally MLK Mass, 2013 St. Henry, Gresham, Centennial Jesuit High drama School uniforms Friar in the mall Holy Trinity food ministry January Book Covers St. Andre Bessette food Year of Faith Mass Nestucca Sanctuary Hillsboro Choirs Father Betschart installation Salem Religious Freedom Rally Year of Faith Vespers, Awards Roy's Catholic School Adelante Mujeres 10th anniversary New Blanchet House Missionaries of Holy Spirit Priest, religious photos Providence Nursing Schools Pioneros Fortnight for Freedom Mark Bentz Deacon Ordination OLL School Walk Through Gaga over science St. Philip Neri Centennial Ordination of Bishop Cary SVDP, Grants Pass Holy Cross School centennial Confirmation - Mount Angel Holy Land Pilgrimage Blanchet Watershed Chrism Mass, 2012 Bishop-designate Cary Pope in Cuba, 2012 SSMO 125th Jubilee Mass Pope Benedict in Mexico 2012 Catholic Charities Celebration 2012 Madeleine Mardi Gras Centennial Rally for Life, 2012 Martin Luther King Jr. Mass 2012 Day Laborers-Guadalupe Guadalupe 2011 Christ the King, Milwaukie, 50th Sesame Doughnuts Central Catholic Volleyball St. Peter Centennial Deacon Ordination, October 2011 St. Agatha Centennial Rosary Bowl 2011 St. Wenceslaus, Scappoose, Centennial Filipino celebration Polish Festival 2011 Holy War Football 2011 World Youth Day 2011 Sun Gold Farm Our Lady of Victory's New Church Freedom Mass 2011 St. Mary Church Steeple Removal Priest reassignments, 2011 Old Catholic Buildings Paige Rice, St. Mary's runner Graduation 2011 Easter vigils 2011 Pastoral Ministry Conference Basketball Holy War 2011 Search for Peace 2011

Novena of Grace 2016

Home : News : Local
Oregon judge rules no employer link between abusive priest and Holy See
Judge Michael Mosman
Judge Michael Mosman
Catholic News Service

An Oregon federal judge ruled Aug. 20 that the Vatican was not the employer of a priest accused of molestation and dismissed a 10-year-old attempt to hold the Holy See liable for sexual abuse.

The lawsuit filed by a Portland-area man attempted to hold the Vatican responsible for him being molested in the 1960s by the late Father Andrew Ronan, a one-time member of the Servite religious order. But the judge said he couldn't find an employment link in the facts and therefore, under the sovereign immunity law, the U.S. court has no jurisdiction.

U.S. District Court Judge Michael Mosman said "there are no facts to create a true employment relationship between Ronan and the Holy See," according to an Associated Press report on what Mosman said from the bench.
Jeffrey Lena, the Vatican's Berkeley, Calif.-based attorney, told Catholic News Service that the ruling was particularly important.

"As the judge stated in open court, he had studied the facts of the case with great care," Lena said. "He recognized the importance of the case."

Jeff Anderson, attorney for the plaintiff, listed as John V. Doe, said in a press release that they would appeal.

"Judge Mosman's thoughtful remarks from the bench clearly expressed his difficulty in deciding the case," Anderson's press release said. "He referred to the case as very troubling and a close call."

Lena said Anderson's description of the judge's remarks was misleading. "He did not say it was a close call on whether Ronan was an employee. That was not a close call." On that issue, the central point of the case, "he said the plaintiffs had not really produced any solid facts to support their theory."

Mosman ruled that there was insufficient evidence to find that the Vatican has both direct and operational control over priests in the United States.

Anderson's statement suggested he's unwilling to concede that point. "We believe that under further scrutiny, the courts will find that Vatican protocols and practice make it clear that obedience to Rome required the secrecy and concealment practiced by priests and bishops as the clergy abuse crisis unfolded in the United States."

In an unusually structured Aug. 20 hearing, Mosman opened the session by announcing that he was inclined to rule in favor of the Holy See and explained his rationale, offering Anderson the chance in the courtroom to expand upon the reams of pages of documents and testimony that he had reviewed.

"He gave the parties ample opportunity to express their views and discuss the evidence before the court," Lena said.

Mosman said that while a priest clearly functions under obligations and rules set by the Holy See, the relationship is not that of employee-employer. He compared the situation to that of attorneys and the state bar association, which sets rules for practicing law, but does not actually employ all the state's attorneys.

Lena said the judge "indicated that there could be kinds of control ... such as general standards or even very detailed control as in the case of the bar association controlling attorneys, but it is not the kind of control that is commensurate with employment."

By dismissing the Holy See from the lawsuit, the judge left just one defendant in the case, the Servite order, according to The Oregonian newspaper. The Chicago and Portland archdioceses, where Ronan worked, previously were dismissed as defendants.

The one-time Servite priest admitted sexually abusing minors in Ireland and Chicago before he was laicized in 1966. He died in 1992.

Lawsuits in other cases against the Holy See filed by Anderson in Kentucky and Wisconsin have been dropped in the last few years.

Some peculiarities of Oregon employment law gave a lawsuit in that state some different characteristics than other states.

In earlier actions, the Holy See had claimed sovereign immunity and sought to have the suit dismissed. Mosman, in a 2006 ruling and then the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in 2009 ruled against the immunity claim.

In 2010, the Holy See asked the Supreme Court to review the 9th Circuit ruling. Acting U.S. Solicitor General Neal Katyal urged the Supreme Court to overturn the ruling on the basis that the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act exempted the Holy See from tort claims. The lower courts had found that Oregon's broad definition of "scope of employment" might apply.

The Supreme Court declined to hear the case, thereby returning the matter to the District Court for consideration. Lena explained that Mosman then was faced with deciding whether, under Oregon law, an employment relationship existed.

To do so, the court had at its disposal all of the materials the Holy See could provide about Ronan and his assignments, Lena said.

"The court examined those documents and the outcome was that there was no evidence that the Holy See was the employer of Ronan, or that it transferred Ronan, or that it knew of the abuse in question until after the abuse had taken place in 1965," Lena said. "The Holy See only learned of the abuse in 1966," after which Ronan was quickly laicized.

Finding that there was no employment relationship, Mosman concluded the court had no jurisdiction over the Holy See and dismissed the case.

Advanced Search

Mary Jo Tully ~ The Path to Resurrection

News | Viewpoints | Faith & Spirituality | Parish and School Life | Entertainment | Obituaries | Find Churches and Schools | About Us | Subscriptions | Advertising
E-Newsletter | RSS Feeds

© 2016 Catholic Sentinel, a service of Oregon Catholic Press

Software © 1998-2016 1up! Software, All Rights Reserved